Lawrence >Restaurants >
Pizza >Sgambati's New York Pizza
1700 Sand Acres Dr, De Pere, WI | Directions 5411544.431360 -88.124342
Their white pizza is amazing. A contrary to the previous review, the sausage they use is awesome. Yes it's cut like pepperoni and spicy, but that's why it's excellent. Their garlic knots are a great appetizer too.
This pizza is terrible…
We looked to the reviews, some good, some bad, and decided to give it a try – what a mistake.
We really wanted it to be good – as we are not pizza “snobs” and enjoy several types of pizza.
We ordered the meat lovers – it says it comes with sausage and meatballs among other things.
Well, when we got it we couldn’t find any sausage or meatballs on it.
There was no sauce that we could taste and the pizza was really dry and spicy.
The crust was rubbery and had no real taste to it – neither did the “cheese”.
We called the next day to ask about the sauce, meatballs, and sausage, and were told by the general manager that the meatballs really aren’t meatballs but a mixture of meatball tasting meat ground up into the consistency of taco meat – what?!
We were also told that the sausage they use is not like the sausage pictured on their menu on their webpage - it is shaped like pepperoni and very spicy…
And as for the sauce we were told, very defensively, that is how they have made the pizza for five years now.
If you like dry, spicy pizza with meat the consistency of dry taco meat then try this pizza it at your own risk - if not find another pizza place - any.
If I could give this pizza zero stars I would – that is how bad it is.
We subsequently found out they opened another pizza place in Green Bay on West Mason Street that didn't stay open long - we can certainly see why.
Great NY style pizza – Tried Sgambati's for something different from the normal and found it very good. Have gone back there a number of times and to their place on W. Mason st and have always had the food hot and the service fast!!
Great pizza! – This is a kind of pizza you don't normally find in the Green Bay area. Big slices, great flavor, great crust. I'll be a regular customer.
Sign in with Facebook Sign in with Facebook to see what your friends are up to!
Do you have a review of Sgambati's New York Pizza on your blog? If you include the Citysearch image link (shown below) in your post, we'll automatically link to your review from the business profile page. Here's how our Linkback system works:
The Linkback system is free and automatic. It's really that easy.
To link to our business profile page, copy the html below to your web page.